deviant ART

[x]

~vforvengeance:iconvforvengeance:

Toh Seng Kai  

  • Status: Member
  • Illustrator
  • Male/Malaysia
  • Offline for 8h 59m 29s
  • Deviant since May 14, 2006, 4:31 AM
  • 56 Deviations
  • 1,445 Deviation Comments
  • 905 Deviant Comments
  • 19 News Comments
  • 3 Forum Posts
  • 16,058 Pageviews

The REAL DEAL and the matter of TRUST

Journal Entry: Mon Apr 14, 2008, 1:22 PM
Okay, first I was really FUCKED up in the first place after reading Mark Simons' article from AWN, which really shows the 'Orphaned Works Legislation' to be such a FUCKED up bill and I couldn't help getting paranoid with Mark's fiery words in every lines he said about the bill and listening to the interview he had with Brad Holland from IPA regarding with the bill. After some clearing ups and researches, I finally got a clear insight at the bill which was posted by Mrs Marybeth Peters, a register of copyrights in the US:[link]

1. Why the bill is proposed?
First, let's look into the Orphaned Works problem, some people who wanted to get old photographs retouched or repaired but were denied service by the photo shops because:
A) Those pictures were taken by the photographer at the wedding then and should be the one (not the customers) who has copyright for the photograph and they need approvals from that guy.
B) The customers don't even know who-the-FUCK photographer at his/her parents' wedding and how the FUCK are they going to trace it? Do photo shops expect their customers to go on a wildgoose chase for some guy who shot their folks wedding 30 years ago?

Other examples are big organisations like museums and documentary filmmakers who want to use archival collections of old photos and celluloid footages and to do that they need approvals from the owners but should if the owners were buried 6 feet deep long long time ago, who the FUCK they're gonna turn to get permissions? At the end, the whole show&tell project FUCKED up all because the owner is DEAD and they can't risked getting HELL lawsuits from the other side.

2. The Proposed Solution
In Marybeth's statements recommended a framework whereby a legitimate orphan works owner who resurfaces may bring an action for “REASONABLE COMPENSATION” against a qualifying user. A user does not qualify for the benefits of orphan works legislation UNLESS he/she first conducts a good faith, reasonably diligent (but unsuccessful) search for the copyright owner.

It allows a copyright owner to present evidence related to the market value of his/hers work and, at the same time, allows the copyright user to more precisely gauge his/hers exposure to liability. Statutory damages are not apply to Orphaned Works but statutory damages are STAYING. If an owner were to emerge, his/hers legal ownership of the copyright in his/hers work is unchanged. Full remedies, including full statutory damages, would be used against both original and new users who are trying to use it for something else.

The copyrights guys also proposed one exception to the basic rule of reasonable compensation, which is a safe-harbor for certain limited uses performed without any purpose of direct or indirect commercial advantage. The exception would apply only where the user STOP using it after receiving NOTICES for infringement and is believed to be critical for orphan works solution. For example, a local museum wants to use multiple Orphan Photos available on its website or in pamphlets, it is possible that reasonable compensation would still rarely conflict with the legitimate interests of the copyright owner.

3. Public Responses:
Generally digital photographers are against this as they find that their works/pictures are sometimes thought to be ORPHANED when they're NOT. That's because their works are NOT WATERMARKED and they uploaded it directly from digicams to PC to sites like Fotopages, Photobuckets, Flickr etc. Unlike both traditional and CG paintings, pictures taken from digicams seldom provide any hard evidences that they OWN the pictures. Therefore, such situations are also the roots of PRECEIVED ORPHANED WORKS. So what are they gonna do? Go back to the old Kodak Film style? Man, even your UGLY ID photo and digital homemade porn videos are considered 'Orphaned' too.

The bill included revisions to the Copyright Office's original proposal and incorporated a number of changes that were designed to protect photographers and other visual artists in particular. These changes included a requirement that users document their searches, a definition of "reasonable compensation" (taken from the Office's Report), and the availability of attorney's fees under circumstances where a user fails to negotiate in good faith with an owner who has previously registered his work.

In conclusion, the bill is hoped to makes things more easier for museums, documentary filmmakers and publishers when it comes to using Orphaned Works where owners are DEAD and Marybeth stressed that the bill does NOT create an EXCEPTION; nor does it rescind an owner's COPYRIGHTS RIGHTS.

Above are are just summarised version and here is my opinions about the bill. It will be beneficial for any organisations to use pictures, footages and even letters which are more than 100 years old where the original owners are DEAD without much hassles with the copyrights laws, after all too many people are scheming enough to make money out of lawsuits by seeking statutory damages.

However, there is just one thing which is the matter of TRUST. How would I know if the law really guarantees that my rights to my works and I'm protected WITHOUT having some MUTHAFUCKAS using my works without my permissions and called my works as "ORPHANED" WITHOUT even did a FUCKING Diligent search? The real problem is that with piracy so RAMPANT these days, MUTHAFUCKAS may use ORPHANED WORKS as an excuse or loophole to get away scot free and we are talking about ABUSE here. Especially stock photos taken from digicams and uploaded online where the stockphotographers can seldom produce any hard evidences that the photos belong to them, even with hi-res photos which could also means that they bought from elsewhere.

What more, with so much hassles with the copyrights laws like the case mentioned above where photo shops won't retouch your parents' worn out wedding photos if you can't get approvals from the guy who shot it 30 years ago. Such hassles are the results of unnecessary acts in the copyrights laws where couples aren't OWNERS to their very OWN wedding albums, so I can't even be entitled rights to my ID photo with my ugly face on it?

As long it doesn't affect artists, writers and photographers who are still ALIVE, I don't FUCKING care about it as long MUTHAFUCKAS don't use that ORPHANED clause or I will FUCKING go after their asses. With image editing sotfwares capable of retouching and wipe away watermarks, MUTHAFUCKAS can FUCKING use that ORPHANED clause to cover up their acts. So what's the best way to protect your works? Never show them? Let's face it, the bill can't fully GUARANTEE protections of owners to their works as long PIRACY and ILLEGAL USES of copyrighted materials are still so RAMPANT where the ORPHANED WORKS clause only applies to those WHO ARE DEAD...

  • Mood: Tired
  • Listening to: SIMONS whines and groans
  • Playing: Grinding Mark with a meat processor
  • Drinking: Beer

Devious Information

  • Current Age: Not really important
  • Current Residence: Shah Alam, Selangor, Malaysia
  • Interests: Art, swim, cycling, read
  • Favourite movie: Anything as long won't bore me to death.
  • Favourite band or musician: U2, Sting, Micheal Jackson, Gloria Estefan, Leslie Cheung, Leon Lai, Jacky Cheung
  • Favourite genre of music: Anything as long it won't bored me to death
  • Favourite artist: Hajime Katoki, Yoji Shinkawa, Chen Wen, Bart Forbes, Bill Sienkiewicz, Robert Peak
  • Favourite poet or writer: Edgar Poe, Confucius
  • Favourite photographer: Richard Avedon, Micheal Yamashita
  • Favourite style or digital art: Traditional art and CG painting
  • Operating System: Windows & Mac OS
  • MP3 player of choice: The last MP3 costs me a PC...
  • Shell of choice: V-powered fuel burns too quickly and expensive.
  • Wallpaper of choice: I only paint walls with fresh paints.
  • Skin of choice: Mine are full of scars.
  • Favourite game: Anything as long it won't bore me to death.
  • Favourite gaming platform: PS2, Dreamcast
  • Favourite cartoon character: Chip n' Dale
  • Personal Quote: God saves the beer, the queen can drinks sea water.
  • Tools of the Trade: Pencil

deviantART Notice

Devious Comments

=Go-Baby-Go:iconGo-Baby-Go: 4 hours 58 minutes ago
Thank You For The:+fav:!!
8-) 8-) 8-)

--
Café Press Linkage>>> [link]
Ick-y MySpace Linkage >>> [link]
Ick-y FaceBook Linkage >>> [link]
~hucky008:iconhucky008: Apr 23, 2008, 3:12:15 PM
yes... to show them the rotten world! and also put Go Nagai stuff when I get to use the multimedia room.

--
This is no random message, after all, I wrote it thinking that somewhere, somehow, someone will read this crappy line XD
~vforvengeance:iconvforvengeance: Apr 22, 2008, 1:35:56 AM
You're a school teacher, you know what good for your students...

--
Remember, remember the Fifth of November
The Gunpowder Treason and Plot
I know of no reason Why the Gunpowder Treason
Should Ever be Forgot
~hucky008:iconhucky008: Apr 21, 2008, 6:32:48 PM
hey, thx for stopping by my blog, but man... you know I'm kidding right?, of course I need -and should- practice more to improve my skills...

but also I cannot but feel admiration for such artists, like yourself. and at a certain point, by definition, admiration involves a certain envy XD

--
This is no random message, after all, I wrote it thinking that somewhere, somehow, someone will read this crappy line XD
~DreamsAddiction:iconDreamsAddiction: Apr 21, 2008, 12:13:05 PM
Impressive gallery mate ^^
*COURTJ3ST3R:iconCOURTJ3ST3R: Apr 20, 2008, 3:10:11 PM
I spy a tag :D
[link]

--
-insert witty signature here-
*GeraldWinslow:iconGeraldWinslow: Apr 19, 2008, 6:26:59 PM
Hello Toh, and thanks for letting the mother hummingbird and her babies fly into your :+fav:s! :bow:
~SealSlammer:iconSealSlammer: Apr 19, 2008, 7:36:21 AM
Thank YOU for the fave. :D

--
It's easy to hate. But trying HARD to hate is fucking retarded

When God breathed life into Adam, he had to ask Mr. T's permission.

When Obi Wan was struck down by Darth Vader, he became Chuck Norris.
~wolf3fenrir:iconwolf3fenrir: Apr 15, 2008, 6:54:19 PM
killer gallery. ^_^ so you get a watch.
=sandrum:iconsandrum: Apr 12, 2008, 2:42:32 AM
Doing ok. Thanks likewise for the fave ;)
~vforvengeance:iconvforvengeance: Apr 12, 2008, 12:12:52 AM
Thanks:rose:

--
Remember, remember the Fifth of November
The Gunpowder Treason and Plot
I know of no reason Why the Gunpowder Treason
Should Ever be Forgot
~Rob-Cavanna:iconRob-Cavanna: Apr 11, 2008, 12:48:03 PM
Many thanks for the :+devwatch:! Love your mech designs -keep it up!
~vforvengeance:iconvforvengeance: Apr 8, 2008, 9:31:25 AM
Thanks:rose:

--
Remember, remember the Fifth of November
The Gunpowder Treason and Plot
I know of no reason Why the Gunpowder Treason
Should Ever be Forgot
~natachen:iconnatachen: Apr 8, 2008, 7:50:01 AM
love your MS Bodhisatva ^^ awesome!
*GeraldWinslow:iconGeraldWinslow: Apr 4, 2008, 7:18:26 AM
Thank you, Toh, for including End of the Trail in your :+fav:s! :bow:
*cottonwings:iconcottonwings: Apr 4, 2008, 1:09:20 AM
so many mechas!! *w*

--
网之初、性本善、打打字、聊聊天! :rage:

~cottonwings-lovers Join it or die.. you know you want to. :headbang:
~Bass-EXE:iconBass-EXE: Apr 3, 2008, 10:51:37 PM
dood youre awesome!
=fire-doused:iconfire-doused: Apr 2, 2008, 11:32:10 PM
Very nice... guess 1st April pranks aren't fun for us old men eh.

--
Teacher: "1 + 1 = ?"
Student: "1 + 1 = 1."
Teacher: "That's incorrect."
Student: "NO WAY! The Boolean Algebra states that I'm correct!"
~vforvengeance:iconvforvengeance: Apr 2, 2008, 11:15:14 PM
Pretty quiet here, except for the stupid mudskip prank pulled by DA and the next day people respond the prank in their own way. If I ever want to play a prank on the 1st of April, I would play it on M and see if he gets a heart attack... Then again, I would be mourning for Leslie Cheung's 4th year since his suicidal death.

--
Remember, remember the Fifth of November
The Gunpowder Treason and Plot
I know of no reason Why the Gunpowder Treason
Should Ever be Forgot
=fire-doused:iconfire-doused: Apr 2, 2008, 11:38:45 AM
Yo there, man. How did 1st April pass for you? Would really like to see you put up a journal on that if you do, heheheh.

--
Teacher: "1 + 1 = ?"
Student: "1 + 1 = 1."
Teacher: "That's incorrect."
Student: "NO WAY! The Boolean Algebra states that I'm correct!"
~Denommus:iconDenommus: Mar 27, 2008, 8:11:15 AM Mood: Wow!
Man, you are my idol.
I really enjoyed your robots and machines. You have a gift.

--
Hoping to work on games.
*ayez:iconayez: Mar 26, 2008, 10:45:44 PM
lolz no I didn't even bring my camera there! XD;
sorry!!

--
EXAMS ENDED!!!
...but I still have lots of assignments to finish. T__T Will be free by the end of May.
*fortissimo:iconfortissimo: Mar 26, 2008, 12:25:00 PM
Found your gallery after seeing some of your comments in Eriance's page. :D Sweet looking mechs, I'll have to drop back when I have more time and have a good look around.

--
Put a Stop to Art Theft: [link]
~vforvengeance:iconvforvengeance: Mar 26, 2008, 3:25:04 AM
Yeah, I went there last sunday. But the whole con is all about online games only.

--
Remember, remember the Fifth of November
The Gunpowder Treason and Plot
I know of no reason Why the Gunpowder Treason
Should Ever be Forgot
~ZhangZhang83:iconZhangZhang83: Mar 26, 2008, 3:12:29 AM
Haha, me too. I also wonder that was him. Do u take some nice picture? Hope u can share some photo with me.

--
一刀兩斷﹗